johnnybear
Member: Rank 6
Well apart from the idea of a gender swapping Doctor being crap, I agree, although I hadn't noticed any mascara on her eye lids! I thought the scene with Capaldi talking to himself was as corny as hell and it was just a waste of time put in because the show was running short! Can't say I think Capaldi was the best Doctor of New Who though. I could sense his Tom Baker velvety tones here and there but he didn't seem to have his own individual identity did he. One minute he was wearing a Hartnell mock up and then Pertwee's series seven attire and then a hoody which didn't suit him, but like you say that was Moffat's fault because in essence the guy just doesn't know how to write for Doctor Who!Capaldi going is so sad, he was brilliant, the best Doctor in NuWho. The tragedy is he was given crap stories. He is the Colin Baker of NuWho.
Not seen the Xmas special yet, been busy watching Shada, but I saw the regeneration scene. This may be picky, but The Doctor CANNOT regenerate already wearing mascara and some sort of face blusher, but we got a close up of mascarad eyes before the big reveal that it's a woman!
JB