Review Welcome to Paradox (1998) - episode 11 "Into the Shop"

Did this episode work flawlessly, or did it need to go into the shop? Grade it now.

  • 10

  • 9

  • 8

  • 7

  • 6

  • 5

  • 4

  • 3

  • 2

  • 1


Results are only viewable after voting.

Brimfin

Member: Rank 3
This week: KITT-Y goes berserk. Yes, this episode has a futuristic car, though not as fancy as the KNIGHT INDUSTRIES TWO THOUSAND, and with a female voice to boot. It starts out well. Our lead character Federal Police Marshall Stu Clemens spots a man robbing an ATM. He flees, but Stu isn’t concerned. His partner will get him. Sure enough, his car arrests and fires an immobilizer ray on the crook allowing Stu to arrest him. But when the guy mouths off to her, she zaps him with another immobilizer beam. Stu is worried so he takes her in for a checkup. Unfortunately, the story takes a little nosedive here. The idiot mechanic working on her spills his coffee into her system. Just when it was looking like it was something in her programming starting to go astray, maybe a god complex developing or something similar, it turns into just a coffee-spill-induced short circuit.

A10, as she is called, gets a list of criminals to be on the lookout for, including one Sheldon Kruger, a murderer and Arbutus Jones, who kidnaps and murders women but so far has hidden the bodies and eluded capture. She polishes off the first name while Stu is in a diner. She stops Sheldon, finds him guilty, and executes him on the spot. Stu arrives as A10 is vacuuming up the ashes into a container in the car. The Captain lets him know this may mean a promotion. The only trouble of course is that it later turns out she nabbed and executed the wrong guy. However for now, she is on the trail of Arbutus Jones, who has kidnapped the former lover of Stu - Diane Harmon. Even though she should report that Stu is personally involved with the victim, she doesn’t – making Stu trust her all the more.

Arbutus sends them on a false trail leaving a dummy with a note behind. A10 smashes through the wall and zaps the dummy until it starts on fire. However, she has seemingly logical reasons for it. The guy left something on the dummy to make it seem like it was human; that’s why she rushed in. When she tried to taser him she didn’t sense a drop in his activity so she kept zapping him.

They follow another lead, but she breaks down at kilometer 12, so Stu has to run to kilometer 16 and call for a mechanic. One arrives and enters the car only to have her call him an intruder and apparently disintegrate him. (We never see what happens but he vanishes off the grid afterward.) But he apparently got her running first, because Stu is able to return and drive her away. But then the precinct captain tells him about A10’s little boo-boo of executing the wrong person and eating her mechanic. He wants her brought into the shop right away and promises he can download the info to another car. But A10 has spotted Diane in Arbutus’s car still alive, so he cuts off the call and goes after her instead. All things considered, I can understand his decision.

They arrive and Stu tries to chase Arbutus. He falls for an old ploy. When he tells him to stop, Arb says “Let me think about this – NO!” and then shoots him. Temporarily down, it’s up to A10 to stop the rapist-murderer. Unfortunately, she mistakes him for Sheldon Kruger and his female accomplice (even though I never remember hearing that Sheldon even had a female accomplice) and kills both of them. Stu cradles her in his arms having lost the love of his life in an attempt to save her. The host says, “Stu took a risk of using an unstable machine to save the woman he loved, but his decision proved tragic. Welcome to paradox.” Well, actually, that’s not how it ended. Instead, she starts to compute that no – Stu is Sheldon Kruger, even though Sheldon 1’s ashes are in her car and Sheldon 2 is dead in front of her. It’s totally idiotic even for a malfunctioning computer. But wait, there’s more! Later on, a new female police officer has been assigned A10; even assuring us it’s the same A10 and not a similar model by showing us that Stu’s favorite squeezer stress reliever – given to him by Diane – is still there, before the office casually tosses it out. When she stops and steps out to eat somewhere, A10 accuses yet another passerby of being Sheldon Kruger. So, let me get this straight, even though A10 has killed two innocent civilians, one mechanic, and one marshal, they still put her back into service again without a massive overhaul? This went from idiotic to insane! It’s like watching a bad horror movie.

So what could have been an intriguing story of a computer being given too much power and wielding it too freely becomes a simple – ooops, I spilled coffee into her circuits and now she thinks everyone is Sheldon Kruger. I can only give it 6 green stress reliever squeezers, with an alien face on front and clearly a Sci-Fi logo on the back.
 

Cloister56

Member: Rank 3
Oh wow it's Bobby. On a related side note I finally finished Twin Peaks Season 2 on my third attempt.

I think shows like Welcome to Paradox and Black Mirror work best when they introduce a new technology, establish it's benefits and then follow it to often unexpected and terrible outcomes.
There is the potential for that here. Before the coffee we do see signs that A10 isn't just behaving as you might expect, delivering a bit of sass to the cash machine robber and then

But when the guy mouths off to her, she zaps him with another immobilizer beam. Stu is worried so he takes her in for a checkup.
Then the coffee. Surely if the mechanic spilled his coffee in an expensive and technologically complicated technology which is armed he would be a bit more concerned before letting it go, especially as it immediately shows signs of impairment. Plus what is that analyser box doing why doesn't it pick up the fault. I guess A10 drives off before the service is complete, but then why does the mechanic just sigh and not shut A10 down right then, or warn everyone? Maybe he was hoping it would be ok and no-one would find out he spilled his coffee in an expensive machine.

Sadly this means instead of gradually and logically exploring where this technology could go wrong without a major fault we have a clear trigger. I guess you could criticize the water proofing and the safe guards in the cars AI but that's for another day.

I guess we do get to explore Clemens confidence in his new technological partner and it seems the level of confidence the system has placed on it. The first time the authorities begin to suspect something is wrong with A10 is when the real Sheldon Kruger is apprehended. Up to then it's all celebrations and talk of promotion. I guess they would have tested the remains and found it didn't match Sheldon Kruger at some point.

It is nice to see that the VW Beetle is the car of the future, perhaps here it is called the VW Beetal. Have I made that joke already, I think I might have done.

I think the last 3rd of the episode does elevate things. We know the car isn't working correctly. Clemens now also knows this. We have seen a white beetle arrive with the service engineer. We haven't seen the service engineer since he entered A10.
Is the shot A10 showing of Arbutus and Diane in a white beetle faked or is it the same white beetle.
Is Harmon chasing the engineer or Arbutus?
There was some tension as A10 reminding us that time was running out while the chief insisted Harmon bring A10 in.

The mystery is quickly solved, Yes it's Arbutus. I think they could have strung this out more, have Harmon creep around the warehouse, perhaps see a figure and shoot, perhaps wounds the guy. He then finds something that points to it being the tech, oh no his trust in A10 was misplaced, he drops his guard and then boom it's Arbutus he gets the drop on him and escapes to the next scene.
Instead we get some ok running around firing wrist lasers at each other.

I think the ending was ok. A10 is still obsessed with Kruger so kills Arbutus, again incorrectly identifying him as Kruger.

Unfortunately, she mistakes him for Sheldon Kruger and his female accomplice (even though I never remember hearing that Sheldon even had a female accomplice) and kills both of them.
Yeah I think this would have worked better if we had seen that. Perhaps a mug shot of Kruger followed by his female partner would have planted the seed.

A10 is fully obsessed then identifying Clemens as Kruger and I assume killing him too.

When she stops and steps out to eat somewhere, A10 accuses yet another passerby of being Sheldon Kruger. So, let me get this straight, even though A10 has killed two innocent civilians, one mechanic, and one marshal, they still put her back into service again without a massive overhaul? This went from idiotic to insane! It’s like watching a bad horror movie.
Yeah this was ridiculous. I think it was completely unnecessary and hurt the episode to include this scene.

Overall I think this episode had some merit. Initially I thought it was a bit crap but typing up my thoughts has made me reconsider a little.

6 earthly remains of Sheldon Kruger when there should only be one, out of 10
 
Top