Watched The Wailing last night. I knew next to nothing going into it; only that it was a haunting/possession-type horror with a lot of buzz about it. So I had no pressures or influences on what I was about to see.
And...I'm not sure what to think. I wanted to like it more. First off, the parts that were good were VERY good. Every scene with the little girl was excellent. And the two scenes of the shaman ritual were absolutely riveting. Some other scenes, especially in the last 30 minutes or so were likewise very intense.
However, much of the movie was so...frustrating. Frustrating because it didn't have to be so bad. There's no reason why the main character and his cohorts had to be so inept. Going for a few laughs here and there is one thing, but making them so cartoonish took me right out of the movie time and time again. I could give example after example, but don't feel like spoiler-boxing a wall of text.
And the plot doesn't add up. I don't mind movies (in fact, I pretty much love movies) where a second viewing allows you to put more pieces together. Movies like Mulholland Dr., Inception, Memento, The Sixth Sense, Jacob's Ladder, A Tale of Two Sisters, etc. Lots of satisfying "aha!" moments upon repeat viewings. Even if an ending is open for interpretation (Inception) where different people will have different takes, that's okay too, as long as the director plays fair. However, with The Wailing, I have no confidence that anything will start to add up. Why? Because apparently the director didn't put anything in there to add up! (and didn't really care). It seemed he was satisfied with merely stringing scenes together (hoping that the audience will like the good scenes so much, they'll forgive him for all the stupid ones), that he didn't give a fuck if it all failed to make a cohesive movie. If I interpret the goings-on one way, there are earlier scenes that do not support (and actively contradict) that interpretation. However, if I interpret the goings on a different way, there are scenes that actively contradict that interpretation. I don't feel like investing another 2.5 hours trying to "understand" what the director has clearly made impossible to understand. But I'll probably watch the shaman exorcism scenes again because that was some of the most amazing spectacle I've ever seen. Absolutely fantastic.
First half of the movie, which mostly features the retarded cop: 2 / 5
Last half of the movie: 4 / 5
Overall: 3 / 5
(shaman scenes: 10 / 5)