So true, but I wonder how much of that is the producers' fault.There are also some who just think their audience are morons.
So true, but I wonder how much of that is the producers' fault.There are also some who just think their audience are morons.
It will be interesting to see how that theme develops over the series. Assuming it does of course. Way too many TV shows introduce fascinating concepts or potential plots and then just ignore them.A government can get away with a lot of evil if it citizens believe the facade that democracy is in place and their elected leaders are working on their behalf. I wonder where the Federation is on this spectrum.
That's almost certainly the case most of the time. I've seen a few interviews with writers over the years where they tell stories about how they were forced to "dumb things down" for the audience. And I guess there's a little bit of logic in that the producers want to appeal to the widest possible audience, including morons. But, as I see it, there are plenty of shows available for morons to watch (*cough*realityTV*cough*). Lets have something for the intelligent viewers to enjoySo true, but I wonder how much of that is the producers' fault.
As a fellow non USAian, I think that this is true. The US Civil War seems to have largely been conflated, in many people's minds, into a pro-slave/anti-slave conflict, where, as far as I can tell, it was about a far wider range of issues, with slavery not really the main consideration, but that issue became important because the economic status of the South was built on slavery far more than the North. In fact, I've seen a quote attributed to Lincoln that if there was a way to end the conflict without changing the status of slavery he'd take it. I'm not sure if that's correctly attributed or not but it does line up with what I've read of the general thinking of the era.From what I know, slavery in mid 19th century was still a thing in different parts of the world. The real problem I think is that the South defended an antiquated economic system, while the North was getting industrialized much more quickly and needed salary-earning workers in their factories. The Southern model was stuck in the 19th century, while the Northern way was aiming at the vibrant 20th century that would begin in a few decades, and which made the United States a huge economic and industrial power.
I just hope that this doesn't result in some people racing ahead. Part of what I'm looking forward to with this group is the discussion of individual episodes and the developing story. If some people are several episodes ahead conversations may become stilted or influenced by things people have seen in future episodes.OKAY FOLKS CHANGE OF PLAN
The first Sage The Seeker has embarked on episode 2. This is cool, we can all proceed at our own pace, some people prefer to binge watch then take a break, or if you know you will be busy a couple of weeks ahead you may want to surge a bit ahead instead of playing catchup. This is all fine.
What I'll now do is put a cast list post on every thread for easier access
They'll be nothing from me announcing the next episode.
Take it as read that by the weekend we'll be onto the next episode
The cast list thread for this episode can be deleted once we're all onto ep.2
Well, its about what you'd expect from a BBC TV show of that era. Sure the effects aren't great by today's standards, or movie standards of that time period, or US TV standards of that period. But, similar to Doctor Who of that era, given what the production team had to work with (in terms of both budget and time) they did a pretty good job and I've certainly seen worse. After all its not quite at Justice League Superman's moustache levels of bad.I'm really glad so far no one had trashed the FX of the show.
I'm glad you enjoyed the first episode of BLAKE'S 7.This was my first time using my TV’s Smartcast feature to watch a show on YouTube, instead of on my computer. While it’s nice to be able to watch a YouTube video on the TV, I was frustrated that I could not go backward or even start over again after it took a few minutes to get the sound level right; I couldn’t even see how much of the show was left when I would pause it. I thought of starting my review by saying, “Well that was a frustrating aggravating way to spend 48 minutes; I hope it gets better later,” and then continuing, “But enough about my first efforts with Smartcast; let’s talk about the show.”
Anyway, I’m brand new to the show and didn’t even read many of the posts of all of you discussing it, as I like to be surprised. This episode certainly didn’t fail to do that. We began with an introduction to our hero as a rather ordinary-seeming fellow being persuaded by two friends to leave his enclosed city to attend a secret meeting “outside.” He meets a secret organization trying to rally against the tyrannical government known as “the Federation.” (I couldn’t help but be amused by the irony that “The Federation” was the benevolent force in the STAR TREK series, and also that the symbol under the title BLAKE’S 7 looked like a sideways version of the insignias worn on the STAR TREK uniforms.) When they ask the man if he remembers someone named Blake who led an attempted insurrection it was only then I really suspected that he was the very Blake they were discussing. Sure enough, he is told of his capture and subsequent brainwashing and begins to remember some of it.
I begin to wonder if some of these people will be part of his “7”. But that is not to be. In the first major “surprise” of the story, futuristic police arrive on the scene. Even though the leader tells him they will surrender peacefully, they instead open fire and slaughter all of them. Blake alone is spared because the Federation fears he would become a martyr for the cause if killed. They try to convince him that he imagined it all while they plot another means to discredit him. Remembering that old principle that if you want to destroy someone’s reputation make them out to be a racist or a child molester, they plant false memories in children of being sexually assaulted by Blake. He is taken to court and quickly convicted and sentenced to a penal colony where new arrivals are often executed, if I heard correctly. Oddly enough, as I watched the trial I was reminded of an episode of LOST IN SPACE where a law enforcement officer declared that they only had time for an “instant trial.” A talking judge’s head appeared on a large display. The officer and the defendants entered data into the machine and it made a summary judgment. The concept was similar here albeit a little more sophisticated with computerized balls of data entered into the system before a verdict was rendered.
After the sentencing, the rest of the episode is really a macguffin of sorts. Blake’s lawyer gets suspicious about his case and investigates. He finds out what we already know – that Blake was framed. He gets evidence and even footage of the dead bodies from the massacre, that were conveniently still lying around rather than having been taken away and burned or something. He tries to arrange for Blake to be removed from the transport ship, but he’s not successful. And at the end of the story, both he and his helping hand wife are shown murdered. In short, the events keeps you occupied but they ultimately go nowhere – except that he did reveal to Blake for sure that he was set up.
While on the transport, Blake meets some other people – one a thief, one a powerful woman. I suspect that they and the other ragtag members of the ship will be the rest of his “7”. (And please do not tell me if I am right or not when I speculate like this. I want to be surprised one way or another. I don’t want someone to respond, “Yes, they will be his 7, and the girl will become his girlfriend whom he’ll marry in Season 3 and...” or “No, they will get massacred like the first group in next week’s show.” Thank you for your understanding.)
The end of the episode could also be like the end of a bleak movie. The attempted heroes are killed, and the traitor/spy of the resistance comments that a transporter accident will be forthcoming. The end. The bad guys win. But instead, as they pull away from the planet, Blake is told that’s the last he’ll ever see of it, but he says with hope and firmness, “No, I’m coming back.”
Overall, an interesting pilot episode. Some of the sets – particularly the courtroom – suffer from a scarcity of props or even walls. But a low budget is acceptable to me when the storylines are imaginative; that’s what I liked about the original DOCTOR WHO. I’ll give this episode an 8 out of 10.
Yeah that bothered me too. Even at the extremely fast past that the legal case seemed to operate, there should have been time for this to be cleared up. I wonder if it says something about the arrogance of the government (or those involved in the conspiracy) that they honestly thought no one would find the evidence? Or possibly it's just lazy writing? Who knows?He gets evidence and even footage of the dead bodies from the massacre, that were conveniently still lying around rather than having been taken away and burned or something.
If I recall correctly, I remember reading that Blake's 7 was often made using recycled Doctor Who sets and props and costumes.Lovely review Brimfin , yes I remember you like 70's Dr Who, this was made by the same team more or less, but with even lower budget, so like you I can forgive cheap fx if the story is good.
And vice versa...If I recall correctly, I remember reading that Blake's 7 was often made using recycled Doctor Who sets and props and costumes.
Both true and false. There was a large number of abolitionists at the time who were trying to end slavery in the south by any means necessary. There were also business owners in the north who were upset that they had to pay wages to workers when there were those in the south who were making a large amount of money on the backs of slaves. The government knew they had two choices - end slavery completely and cause a rift in the nation, or keep going as we were, and allow the states with slavery still instated to keep on, but not allow it to spread to the territories, which was balked at by slave owners wishing to travel west. And yes, Lincoln did, indeed, state that he would have allowed it to continue if it it would end the war.As a fellow non USAian, I think that this is true. The US Civil War seems to have largely been conflated, in many people's minds, into a pro-slave/anti-slave conflict, where, as far as I can tell, it was about a far wider range of issues, with slavery not really the main consideration, but that issue became important because the economic status of the South was built on slavery far more than the North. In fact, I've seen a quote attributed to Lincoln that if there was a way to end the conflict without changing the status of slavery he'd take it. I'm not sure if that's correctly attributed or not but it does line up with what I've read of the general thinking of the era.
While this isn't a new concept by any means, it is intriguing that only a year before that, we saw something similar with the Stormtroopers in Star Wars. Another thing that does is it creates a lack of sympathy for characters like that, so when you see them die, you feel nothing for them, other than feeling that the bad guy got his comeuppances.To carry out such atrocities they must be brainwashed into the Federation belief system, therefore dehumanized, hence the uniforms, a metaphor perhaps to indicate their lack of humanity.
It's been a big thing here for a few decades now, and while I don't mind it, it gives you a feature film feeds you everything you need to know - characters, backstory, motivations, locations, etc. While I like a little mystery on the journey, most Americans need to know everything about the show so they know what they are getting into. In that same vein, it's how you can't have an upcoming show or movie without multiple spoilers, bonus clips, teasers, and the like. Again, I don't mind seeing something to get me excited, but most audiences seem to want to know everything about a movie or show before they even watch it. If it's a genre I like, or a franchise I'm a fan of, etc., I'm going to watch it. Unfortunately, most of my fellow countrymen (and women) are too dumb and need everything spoon-fed to them.Two hour pilots have never been a standard way for British shows to begin, that's an American concept,no idea really why, cultural differences maybe
Sweet!Everyone I think has reviewed ep.1 , so ep.2 whenever you want, see you there;
EPISODE 2 -SPACE FALL.
In my opinion it is going to be almost impossible to prevent this kind of problem from happening. While I think it is a problem, it takes a lot of effort for someone, especially a big fan, to "pretend" they don't what happens next or make more superficial non-spoiler comments that don't give away information that newcomers don't have yet. But ideally, I'd like to stay as "virgin" as possible and find out things as they happen. I'll give two examples of how this has benefited me.I just hope that this doesn't result in some people racing ahead. Part of what I'm looking forward to with this group is the discussion of individual episodes and the developing story. If some people are several episodes ahead conversations may become stilted or influenced by things people have seen in future episodes.
Oh, so it is a unified Earth administration? I thought this was something else. Well, I wasn't sure what this was.this tells us that in B7 the unified Earth administration is the result of the worst traits of humanity exemplified as compared to Star Trek's kindly federation.
I hate long pilots. I don't even know if I'm gonna enjoy the show and they already want me to commit two hours of my time to it. If I want to watch something that lasts two hours, I watch a movie, not a TV show.Two hour pilots have never been a standard way for British shows to begin, that's an American concept
Not props exactly, but I think I recognized some of the soft furniture as the same type used in Robots of Death. :) (establishing nerd cred)If I recall correctly, I remember reading that Blake's 7 was often made using recycled Doctor Who sets and props and costumes.
Your "nerd cred" is accepted...Hi! (waves)
I was with the Sages for a short stint as IMDb died and had to bow out in the middle of Kolchak. If things turn out well over the next few weeks I hope to return and go through Blake and Star Cops with you.
Not props exactly, but I think I recognized some of the soft furniture as the same type used in Robots of Death. :) (establishing nerd cred)
Somewhere in this thread you guys were talking about the advocate Taron and his wife, whether they should not have been more aware how rigged the system is seeing as they are a part of it. Can't find where that went, but I'm speculating...maybe the reason Taron was assigned to Blake was to satisfy the appearance of a fair trial giving him counsel that was honest but naïve and inexperienced?