chainsaw_metal1
Member: Rank 8
No, because those two detectives aren't in the zetigeist as much as Holmes is. Holmes is the detective everyone knows. Sure, the casual observer may have heard of Marple or Poirot or Dupin, and many know of the show Murder, She Wrote, but unless you're going for a Kevin Smith-style obscure reference, you're not going to call someone Jessica Fletcher because someone they got something right (I mean, you or I would, because fuck stupid people, although calling them C. Auguste Dupin would cause their heads to spin, especially when you go into an hour long spiel about how Doyle ripped of Dupin to create Holmes, but I digress).Shall we now be getting MISTER MARPLE and MURDER HE WROTE also?
And because of that, they use Holmes' popularity to cash in on. Anyone can do a Holmes spinoff, but oh sweet Aphrodite in a gimp suit, Sherlock's a woman now, and suddenly you have everyone declaring it's daring and people will throw their money down to see it (even though it's certainly not new, just one more attempt to get money out of an audience.